Straight Up on Dining Out | Positano

POSITANO

West Annapolis’s Dining Room

by Christine Fillat

 

Architecture by Hammond Wilson Architects  |  Interior Design by Design House  |  Photography by Tawney Holmes of Dagment Photography, courtesy of Design House

 

West Annapolis is a very residential neighborhood with the benefit of a shopping district and a few dining options. Positano, its newest dining venue, is already well appreciated by Annapolitans. From its front porch tables to the indoor dining and bar areas, the place is packed, even on a Wednesday night. There is a buzz in the air with families, date night couples, and girls’ night diners alike. 

This large restaurant is ideally suited for its role as a neighborhood dining room. The venue is spacious, with lots of tables and a long bar—perfect for dining and watching some sports event on one of two flat-screen TVs. While the vibe is casual, the interior is sophisticated, with contemporary lighting and a carefully controlled color scheme. Graphic Italian beverage posters decorate the walls. There are, however, lots of hard surfaces, making the noise level something to contend with. Even with just a few people in the room, it is a bit noisy.

A beautiful tiled pizza oven and shelves stacked with pizza boxes reveal Positano’s big star. The pizza here is superb. Our Pizza alla Nonna, garlicky and cheesy, is chewy and delicious. The menu features eleven pizzas; it would be fun to try them all! 

The appetizer meatballs are beautifully formed, made with a combination of ground beef and pork, served with a dollop of burrata, and sit in a pool of tomato sauce. If only the meatballs were seasoned. With seasoning or herbs, this would have made a great dish.

Mafaldine al Tartufo is made with a beautiful, long, ruffled pasta in a truffle cream sauce. This dish is disappointing. The sauce is grainy and lacks the silky smoothness one would expect from a cream sauce. There are tiny bits of truffle in evidence, but very little of the truffle flavor. 

The salmon entrée, however, is a triumph. Garnished with an olive tapenade, it is perfectly cooked with a side of garlic mashed potatoes and roasted Brussels sprouts, broccoli, and squash. This delectable dish would have been perfectly satisfying had it not been served on a cold plate; the food just didn’t stay hot.

In fact, every dish we were served arrived on a cold plate. This is a simple fix, one that an astute kitchen could easily remedy just by making sure all the plates are warm before they go out to the dining room.

The radicchio and pear salad is exceptional: adorned with arugula, blue cheese, pomegranate seeds, heirloom tomatoes, and pecans candied just so subtly to add crunch. The vinaigrette is right on. And the slice of cheesecake is creamy and delicious. 

Elements of our meal at Positano shine, but not the whole constellation. The food is beautifully presented and almost perfect. But the evening we visited, the restaurant was busy, the service was somewhat chaotic, and we were shown to a table in the outside dining area that needed cleaning. On other visits, however, the service was fine and attentive. With a little extra attention, this popular restaurant has the potential to be the best in every way. 

 

 

Positano

106 Annapolis Street | 410.621.9374 | positanoannapolis.com

HOURS:
Mon – Thurs: 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Fri – Sat: 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Sun: 11:00 am – 10:00 pm

 

 

© Annapolis Home Magazine
Vol. 17, No. 6 2026